Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
Part Podcast,
Part Time Machine
Part Podcast,
Part Time Machine
Brandon Vogt sits down with great minds from the past—atheists, saints, converts, and critics—for a candid conversation about life’s biggest questions.
Some come to defend the faith. Others come to bury it. All come to talk.
Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
Part Podcast,
Part Time Machine
Brandon Vogt sits down with great minds from the past—atheists, saints, converts, and critics—for a candid conversation about life’s biggest questions.
Some come to defend the faith. Others come to bury it. All come to talk.
Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
SEASON 1: The Critics
SEASON 1:
The Critics
God is dead? Religion is wish fulfillment? Miracles are nonsense? What happens when you challenge Christianity’s toughest opponents to a second round? In Season 1, Brandon Vogt talks with eight legendary critics—Kant, Nietzsche, Hume, and others—for sharp, honest conversations that pull no punches:
- Friedrich Nietzsche: “Is God dead?”
- Immanuel Kant: “Can morality exist without God?”
- Sigmund Freud: “Is religion just a comforting psychosis?”
- Karl Marx: “Is religion the opiate of the masses?”
- Voltaire: “Has Christianity done more harm than good?”
- David Hume: “Can we believe in miracles?”
- Jean-Paul Sartre: “Can life have meaning without God?”
- Baruch Spinoza: “Is the Bible divine revelation or human invention?”
God is dead? Religion is wish fulfillment? Miracles are nonsense? What happens when you challenge Christianity’s toughest opponents to a second round? In Season 1, Brandon Vogt talks with eight legendary critics—Kant, Nietzsche, Hume, and others—for sharp, honest conversations that pull no punches:
1. Friedrich Nietzsche: “Is God dead?”
2. Immanuel Kant: “Can morality exist without God?”
3. Sigmund Freud: “Is religion just a comforting psychosis?”
4. Karl Marx: “Is Religion the opiate of the masses?”
5. Voltaire: “Has Christianity done more harm than good?”
6. David Hume: “Can we believe in miracles?”
7. Jean-Paul Sartre: “Can life have meaning without God?”
8. Baruch Spinoza: “Is the Bible divine revelation or human invention?”
Christianity steps into the arena. . .
Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
Sign up for FREE so you never miss an episode!
SEASON 1: The Critics
SEASON 1:
The Critics
God is dead? Religion is wish fulfillment? Miracles are nonsense? What happens when you challenge Christianity’s toughest opponents to a second round? In Season 1, Brandon Vogt talks with eight legendary critics—Kant, Nietzsche, Hume, and others—for sharp, honest conversations that pull no punches:
- Friedrich Nietzsche: “Is God dead?”
- Immanuel Kant: “Can morality exist without God?”
- Sigmund Freud: “Is religion just a comforting psychosis?”
- Karl Marx: “Is religion the opiate of the masses?”
- Voltaire: “Has Christianity done more harm than good?”
- David Hume: “Can we believe in miracles?”
- Jean-Paul Sartre: “Can life have meaning without God?”
- Baruch Spinoza: “Is the Bible divine revelation or human invention?”
God is dead? Religion is wish fulfillment? Miracles are nonsense? What happens when you challenge Christianity’s toughest opponents to a second round? In Season 1, Brandon Vogt talks with eight legendary critics—Kant, Nietzsche, Hume, and others—for sharp, honest conversations that pull no punches:
1. Friedrich Nietzsche: “Is God dead?”
2. Immanuel Kant: “Can morality exist without God?”
3. Sigmund Freud: “Is religion just a comforting psychosis?”
4. Karl Marx: “Is Religion the opiate of the masses?”
5. Voltaire: “Has Christianity done more harm than good?”
6. David Hume: “Can we believe in miracles?”
7. Jean-Paul Sartre: “Can life have meaning without God?”
8. Baruch Spinoza: “Is the Bible divine revelation or human invention?”
Christianity steps into the arena...
SEASON 2: The Converts
Hear from brilliant minds who made the dramatic leap into the Catholic Church. From philosophers and poets to rebels and mystics, these voices reveal what drew them from doubt to faith.
- St. Paul
- St. Augustine
- St. John Henry Newman
- G.K. Chesterton
- St. Edith Stein
- Dorothy Day
- Thomas Merton
- + more!
SEASON 3: The Apologists
Meet the great defenders of the faith. From the early martyrs to modern masters, they show that faith and reason are not enemies but allies in the search for truth.
- St. Irenaeus
- St. Justin Martyr
- St. Augustine
- St. Thomas Aquinas
- Blaise Pascal
- St. John Henry Newman
- Fulton Sheen
- + more!
SEASON 4: The Storytellers
The literary giants whose tales have shaped civilizations and stirred souls for centuries. From ancient epics to modern parables, these masters illustrate how fiction unveils truth.
- Homer
- Dante
- William Shakespeare
- Jane Austen
- Fyodor Dostoevsky
- Flannery O'Connor
- + more!
SEASON 5: The Saints
Watch the conversations with some of the Church’s most beloved saints, men and women whose lives of holiness continue to shape the faith of millions.
- St. Augustine
- St. Benedict
- St. Francis of Assisi
- St. Thomas Aquinas
- St. Joan of Arc
- St. Thomas More
- St. Ignatius of Loyola
- St. Thérèse of Lisieux
- + more!
SEASON 6: The Protestants
A Catholic debates the reformers, revivalists, and rebels who reshaped the Christian world. Listen as they wrestle with Scripture, authority, grace, and what it means to follow Christ.
- Martin Luther
- John Calvin
- Ulrich Zwingli
- Jonathan Edwards
- John Wesley
- Søren Kierkegaard
- + more!
SEASON 7: The Scriptures
From patriarchs and prophets to kings and poets, this season brings the voices of the Old Testament to life, those who helped form the foundation of faith.
- Abraham
- Job
- Moses
- David
- Solomon
- Elijah
- Isaiah
- Jeremiah
- + more!
Don't miss an episode!
SEASON 2: The Converts
Hear from brilliant minds who made the dramatic leap into the Catholic Church. From philosophers and poets to rebels and mystics, these voices reveal what drew them from doubt to faith.
- St. Paul
- St. Augustine
- St. John Henry Newman
- G.K. Chesterton
- St. Edith Stein
- Dorothy Day
- Thomas Merton
- + more!
SEASON 3: The Apologists
Meet the great defenders of the faith. From the early martyrs to modern masters, they show that faith and reason are not enemies but allies in the search for truth.
- St. Irenaeus
- St. Justin Martyr
- St. Augustine
- St. Thomas Aquinas
- Blaise Pascal
- St. John Henry Newman
- Fulton Sheen
- + more!
SEASON 4: The Storytellers
The literary giants whose tales have shaped civilizations and stirred souls for centuries. From ancient epics to modern parables, these masters illustrate how fiction unveils truth.
- Homer
- Dante
- William Shakespeare
- Jane Austen
- Fyodor Dostoevsky
- Flannery O'Connor
- + more!
SEASON 5: The Saints
Conversations with some of the Church’s most beloved saints, men and women whose lives of holiness continue to shape the faith of millions.
- St. Augustine
- St. Benedict
- St. Francis of Assisi
- St. Thomas Aquinas
- St. Joan of Arc
- St. Thomas More
- St. Ignatius of Loyola
- St. Thérèse of Lisieux
- + more!
SEASON 6: The Protestants
A Catholic debates the reformers, revivalists, and rebels who reshaped the Christian world. Listen as they wrestle with Scripture, authority, grace, and what it means to follow Christ.
- Martin Luther
- John Calvin
- Ulrich Zwingli
- Jonathan Edwards
- John Wesley
- Søren Kierkegaard
- + more!
SEASON 7: The Scriptures
From patriarchs and prophets to kings and poets, this season brings the voices of the Old Testament to life, those who helped form the foundation of faith.
- Abraham
- Job
- Moses
- David
- Solomon
- Elijah
- Isaiah
- Jeremiah
- + more!
Don't miss an episode!
How it Works
Ever wish you could talk with Augustine about his conversion?
Challenge Nietzsche on Christian morality?
Ask Dante to explain his Divine Comedy?
That’s what you’ll find on Dead Men Talking. Catholic host Brandon Vogt shares one-on-one conversations with history’s most influential figures. Through lively, respectful dialogue, Brandon explores their biggest ideas—sometimes pushing back, sometimes agreeing, always digging deeper.
These aren’t dry lectures or dusty biographies. They’re real conversations about God, truth, morality, and the meaning of life.
The guest might be a fierce opponent of Christianity. Or a saint. Or a literary legend. But all come ready for one thing: a good conversation.
How it Works
Ever wish you could talk with Augustine about his conversion?
Challenge Nietzsche on Christian morality?
Ask Dante to explain his Divine Comedy?
That’s what you’ll find on Dead Men Talking. Catholic host Brandon Vogt shares one-on-one conversations with history’s most influential figures. Through lively, respectful dialogue, Brandon explores their biggest ideas—sometimes pushing back, sometimes agreeing, always digging deeper.
These aren’t dry lectures or dusty biographies. They’re real conversations about God, truth, morality, and the meaning of life.
The guest might be a fierce opponent of Christianity. Or a saint. Or a literary legend. But all come ready for one thing: a good conversation.
Frequently Asked Questions
This is wild 
How did you do this??
“Dead Men Talking” reflects a groundbreaking use of AI technology. Developed in partnership between Brandon Vogt (founder of ClaritasU) and Fuzati (a leading Catholic marketing agency), the series uses multiple AI tools to generate remarkably lifelike scripts, voices, and video. The result? A first-of-its-kind experience: AI-generated conversations with history’s greatest minds.
Like any powerful tool, AI raises serious moral questions. But rather than reject it outright, we believe Catholics should explore creative, ethical ways to use AI for the common good. “Dead Men Talking” is one such example: it presents complex thinkers in a fresh, engaging way, especially for audiences who might never otherwise encounter their ideas. We hope the series serves as a springboard, leading viewers back to each figure's original writings for deeper reflection.
In an ideal world, we’d love to use skilled human impersonators for every episode—and we plan to do so in the future for select guests. But AI gives us an extraordinary opportunity: to quickly and affordably bring dozens of historical figures to life with a high level of fidelity to their thought, speech, and personality. It’s not perfect, but it opens creative doors that would otherwise remain closed.
Absolutely! Transparency is essential. These are not deepfakes. These are clearly AI-generated reenactments—not authentic historical footage, and not meant to deceive. To avoid confusion, we’ve made a key editorial decision: we won’t feature anyone who appeared frequently on video in real life. That means no modern leaders or saints—generally, no one post-1930—with a few careful exceptions.
We try our absolute best! For each guest, we feed their writings and speeches into a large-language model to generate responses grounded in their actual words and ideas. We aim to capture not just what they said, but also how they said it—their tone, cadence, and personality. Our goal is respectful accuracy: letting each thinker speak for themselves as faithfully as possible.
Definitely! The word “Men” in “Dead Men Talking” is used in the traditional, inclusive sense of “mankind.” We’ve lined up several women as guests—giants of intellect, faith, and literature—who will appear in upcoming seasons.
ClaritasU is the online platform created by Brandon Vogt to help Catholics get clear and confident about their faith. Featuring 40 video courses on hot-button issues, all taught by Brandon, ClaritasU will help you:
- Know exactly what to say and how to say it when sharing your faith with others.
- Stay on top of today’s hot-button topics, such as IVF, atheism, and transgenderism, and how to discuss them like an expert.
- Learn the faith from leading Catholic scholars, authors, and speakers, including Fr. Mike Schmitz, Dr. Peter Kreeft, and Dr. Brant Pitre.
"Dead Men Talking" is an initiative of ClaritasU.
Enjoy Dead Men Talking? Learn how to dialogue like Brandon...
Get all 3 volumes of his bestselling book series What to Say and How to Say It for just $7 (with free shipping!) plus one FREE month of ClaritasU!
ClaritasU is an ever-growing library of online courses designed to help you share your Catholic faith with clarity and confidence. Never get tongue-tied again when a family member, friend, or coworker asks questions like:
- Why is the Church against IVF when it claims to be pro-life?
- What’s the big deal with two men getting married?
- How could a loving, all-powerful God allow so much suffering in the world?
- Shouldn’t couples be able to use contraception to plan their family size?
- And more!
3 books + ClaritasU = $7 (w/ free shipping)
Enjoy Dead Men Talking? Learn how to dialogue like Brandon...
Get all 3 volumes of his bestselling book series What to Say and How to Say It for just $7 (with free shipping!) plus one FREE month of ClaritasU!
3 books + ClaritasU =
$7 (w/ free shipping)
ClaritasU is an ever-growing library of online courses designed to help you share your Catholic faith with clarity and confidence. Never get tongue-tied again when a family member, friend or coworker asks questions like:
- Why is the Church against IVF when it claims to be pro-life?
- What’s the big deal with two men getting married?
- How could a loving, all-powerful God allow so much suffering in the world?
- Shouldn’t couples be able to use contraception to plan their family size?
- And more!
MEET
BRANDON VOGT
Brandon Vogt is a Catholic new media pioneer. He is the bestselling author of thirteen books and the founder of ClaritasU, which trains Catholics how to talk about their faith, especially hot-button issues.
He works as the Senior Publishing Director for Bishop Robert Barron’s Word on Fire Catholic Ministries, where he has published over 150 books selling 7 million copies.
He has been named one of the Top 30 Catholics Under 30 and was identified as “one of the U.S. Catholic leaders of today” by The Catholic Herald. His books have been #1 Amazon bestsellers and earned multiple first place awards from the Catholic Press Association and the Association of Catholic Publishers.
Brandon's work has been featured by several media outlets, including NPR, Fox News, CBS, EWTN, Vatican Radio, Our Sunday Visitor, National Review and Christianity Today.
MEET BRANDON VOGT
Brandon Vogt is a Catholic new media pioneer. He is the bestselling author of thirteen books and the founder of ClaritasU, which trains Catholics how to talk about their faith, especially hot-button issues.
He works as the Senior Publishing Director for Bishop Robert Barron’s Word on Fire Catholic Ministries, where he has published over 150 books, selling 7 million copies.
He has been named one of the Top 30 Catholics Under 30 and was identified as “one of the U.S. Catholic leaders of today” by The Catholic Herald. His books have been #1 Amazon bestsellers and earned multiple first-place awards from the Catholic Press Association and the Association of Catholic Publishers.
Brandon's work has been featured by several media outlets, including NPR, Fox News, CBS, EWTN, Vatican Radio, Our Sunday Visitor, National Review and Christianity Today.